Nancy Drew: The Secret of the Old Clock

Review by MrLipid
September 2005

Nancy's Back ... In Time!

The Secret of the Old Clock brings the number of games in the Nancy Drew series to an even dozen. While this is an impressive accomplishment for any series, that's not Clock's only distinction. The game is based on the first book in the Nancy Drew canon, the game's release date is the 75th anniversary of that book's publication, and the game is done in period, right down to Nancy's more-or-less Model A roadster. Clock carries all this baggage effortlessly, providing players with one of the most sprightly entries in the series.

Hot Wheels!

The menu system and interface of Clock will be immediately familiar to anyone who has ever played a Nancy Drew game. One chooses to play as a Junior or Senior detective with difficulty levels for certain puzzles adjusted accordingly. Driving the roadster might seem a bit daunting at first, since one drives it by leading it with the cursor. After a few spins around Titusville, though, players will be doing four-wheel drifts and 360-degree spins with no trouble. As long as care is taken to avoid the potholes, there'll be no need to change a tire. And as long as puddles are avoided during the thrilling chase finale (puddles slow down Nancy's roadster), the villain will have no chance of escaping.

Considering that the game has "clock" in its name, it seems ironic that Clock dispenses with the "advance time by having Nancy sleep" feature. Once the game begins, the sun never sets. As someone who never much cared for the in-game timepiece, I didn't mind its absence.

Our Story So Far ...

Only purists are likely to object to the conflation of the plots of two Nancy Drew books (The Secret of the Old Clock and The Mystery at Lilac Inn) to produce the plot of the game. The game's story links the greed of Richard Topham for the estate of Josiah Crowley from the original Secret with the lost jewels of Emily Crandall from The Mystery at Lilac Inn. The resulting story opens with poor Emily mourning the loss of her mother. A friend of her mother's has come to help Emily run the Lilac Inn. Did Josiah Crowley really leave his money to Topham? Is Jim Archer, the banker, on the level? Clues point, as is usual in Nancy Drew games, everywhere. Assuming Emily is innocent, the villain could be any of the other fully animated characters.

Timeless or Just Old?

Clock, by putting Nancy back in the era of her birth as a character, provides an object lesson in why Nancy is such a durable heroine. Even in the midst of the Depression, Nancy proves that a good heart, a keen mind and an observant eye could bring order and harmony to the world. Relieved of the modern conveniences of a cell phone or the internet, Nancy has ample opportunities to display the resourcefulness that made her a star.

In the world before cell phones, Nancy must use a pay phone. Every call costs a nickel, and Nancy's only got $3.50 in her purse. Would the folks at Her Interactive drop in this resource management element without providing a way for Nancy to pick up some spare change? Of course not. Whenever she pleases, Nancy can jump into her snazzy blue roadster and deliver telegrams all over Titusville for an impressive twenty-five cents apiece. And, like it or not, Nancy will spend time on the road delivering telegrams.

Only Money Makes the Mare Run

There are three separate instances in the game where only money will get the job done, and that means navigating, from an overhead view, the map of Titusville. Avoid the potholes or risk a flat tire and a $2 tire repair fee at Zippy Gas. Keep the roadster's gas tank filled or risk a $5 towing fee. Fortunately, there is a puzzle to solve at Zippy Gas that can get Nancy back in action in case she's too broke to pay for tire repairs or towing.

The driving sections of Clock, underscored with tunes that Raymond Scott imagined but never wrote down, brings an engaging velocity to the proceedings. They also give the player an opportunity to learn the layout of the roads in Titusville—something that will eventually prove essential.

Pleasing Diversions

Between arriving at the inn in the amazingly shiny blue roadster and pushing that roadster to its limits in the thrilling chase finale, Nancy must solve a pleasing variety of puzzles. While most lend themselves to contemplation, some require a bit of eye-hand coordination. There is a miniature golf minigame (which can be skipped), a bit of fishing and the dreaded sewing machine. The sewing machine puzzle requires a steady hand as Nancy attempts to stitch a clean line. Suggestion: Move your mouse cursor speed and acceleration toward the slow end. This will smooth out any twitches and help keep your seam true.

On a More Serious Note

The team at Her Interactive, by setting Clock in the Depression, have taken the bold step of letting the Depression weigh, however gently, on the game's mood. The music is sprightly, as it was in the Depression, but money worries remain. Emily may lose the Lilac Inn if the inheritance of Josiah Crowley winds up going to someone else. The residents of Titusville are not immune to the money drought spreading across the country. Nancy cannot solve the mystery without earning money for gas and other necessities. For those playing this game with their children, this could be an opportunity to discuss this bleak period in America's economic history.

Clock is the first Nancy Drew game to use black-and-white still photographs (reminiscent of Noir: A Shadowy Thriller) to provide visuals for some of the places (Zippy Gas, a mansion, an orphanage, a print shop) Nancy visits. While initially somewhat jarring, the photos contribute to the period mood.

Back to the Future

Clock, with its sunny exteriors and perpetual daylight, feels like the adventure game equivalent of a beach book. It's light, bright, and fun. For those who found Nancy's previous outing, Curse of Blackmoor Manor, more to their liking, Nancy's next adventure, Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon, looks a bit more moody. And a bit more modern. Nancy will be sporting a new camera cell phone for taking pictures and calling for hints. She'll be joined by Frank and Joe Hardy, and there will be pachinko to play, heirloom dolls to sort and short-order cooking to do. In other words, another entry in the irresistibly predictable adventures of the indestructible Ms. Drew. I can't wait. The End

The Verdict

The Lowdown

Developer: Her Interactive
Publisher: Her Interactive
Release Date: July 2005

Available for: Windows

Four Fat Chicks Links

Player Feedback


Click to enlarge Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge Click to enlarge
Click to enlarge Click to enlarge

System Requirements

Windows 98/Me/2000/XP
400 MHz or greater Pentium II or equivalent class CPU
64 MB of RAM
300 MB or more free hard drive space
16 MB DirectX compatible video card
16-bit DirectX compatible sound card
12X CD-ROM drive

Where to Find It

Links provided for informational purposes only. FFC makes no warranty with regard to any transaction entered into by any party(ies).

Copyright © Electric Eye Productions. All rights reserved.
No reproduction in whole or in part without express written permission.